- Mathematics
- Class 9
- Project 11
11The Biggest Box: Cutting Corners to Maximise Volume
From a 24 cm × 24 cm square of card, cut equal squares from each corner and fold up the sides to make an open tray. How big should the corner cut be to hold the most? Teams build trays with cuts from 1 cm to 6 cm, fill them with rice to compare, write the volume formula V = x(24 − 2x)², and use a table and graph to find the best cut.
- Class and age
- Class 9 · 14–15
- Activity type
- Group
- Time needed
- 60–90 minutes
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Estimated budget
- ৳0–৳30
Mathematical concepts
- Volume of a cuboid
- Writing a formula in one variable
- Tables of values and graphing a curve
- Finding a maximum
- Domain: which values of x make sense
Learning objectives
- Build trays and compare their capacity by experiment.
- Write the volume as a function of the cut size.
- Use a table and graph to find the maximum.
- Explain why very small and very large cuts both give small volumes.
Real-life connection
Packaging factories cut and fold sheets of card and metal into trays and boxes. Choosing dimensions that give the most space from the least material saves money.
Materials required
- Thin card or old cereal boxes cut into 24 cm squares (6 per group)
- Ruler, pencil, scissors, tape
- Rice and a measuring cup (or a small container to count scoops)
- Graph paper or spreadsheet
Step-by-step instructions
- Predict: which cut size from 1 to 6 cm will make the biggest tray?
- Each group makes trays with cuts of 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 cm.
- Fill each tray level with rice and measure how much it holds.
- For a cut of x cm, the base is (24 − 2x) by (24 − 2x) and the height is x. Write the formula for V.
- Calculate V for x = 1 to 11 in a table.
- Plot V against x and find the highest point.
- Try x = 3.5, 4.5 and other decimals near the top to get closer to the best value.
- Compare the experiment, the table and the graph. Write a conclusion and explain why x cannot be 12 or more.
Mathematical explanation
V = x(24 − 2x)². When x is small the tray is wide but shallow; when x is large it is deep but the base shrinks quickly. The table gives V = 484 at x = 1, 972 at x = 3, 1024 at x = 4 and 980 at x = 5, so the maximum is at x = 4 cm (one sixth of the side), with a volume of 1024 cm³. If x reached 12, the base would vanish, so only 0 < x < 12 makes sense. Finding a maximum like this is a first step towards calculus.
Expected project output
A set of trays, a rice-capacity table, a formula, a table of values and a graph showing the maximum.
Skills developed
- Modelling with functions
- Optimisation
- Linking experiment and theory
- Careful construction
Assessment criteria
- Trays are built accurately.
- The formula is correct and explained.
- The table and graph are accurate and the maximum is identified.
- The sensible range for x is explained.
Extension challenge
Repeat with a 20 cm × 30 cm rectangle. Is the best cut still one sixth of a side? Use a spreadsheet to search.
Safety and inclusion
Use scissors carefully. Sweep up spilled rice so nobody slips.