- Mathematics
- Class 9
- Project 19
19The Pendulum Puzzle: When a Straight Line Is the Wrong Model
Teams hang a weight on a string and time 10 swings for lengths from 10 cm to 160 cm. A graph of time against length is clearly curved, so a straight line fails. Students then test whether time is proportional to the square root of length by plotting time against √length, discovering a straight line through the origin, and use the model to design a pendulum that swings exactly once per second.
- Class and age
- Class 9 · 14–15
- Activity type
- Group
- Time needed
- 60–90 minutes
- Difficulty
- Challenging
- Estimated budget
- ৳0–৳30
Mathematical concepts
- Timing many swings to reduce error
- Non-linear relationships
- Square roots
- Transforming data to get a straight line
- Direct proportion through the origin
Learning objectives
- Collect accurate timing data.
- Recognise when a linear model does not fit.
- Transform data to reveal a hidden relationship.
- Use the model to design for a target.
Real-life connection
Pendulum clocks kept time for centuries. Engineers still use the same idea of transforming data to find laws in fields from medicine to economics.
Materials required
- String, a small heavy object (a bunch of keys or a nut)
- A fixed support (a door frame hook or a ruler taped firmly to a table edge)
- Measuring tape, stopwatch or phone
- Calculator, graph paper
Step-by-step instructions
- Hang the weight so the length from the support to the centre of the weight is 10 cm.
- Pull it a small distance to the side (a small angle) and let go. Time 10 full swings and divide by 10.
- Repeat for lengths 20, 40, 60, 80, 120 and 160 cm. Do each length twice.
- Plot time against length. Is it a straight line?
- Calculate √length for each and plot time against √length.
- Draw the line of best fit. Does it pass through the origin? Find its gradient k so that T = k√L.
- Use your model to find the length that gives exactly 1 second per swing (back and forth). Build it and test.
- Write a short report on how transforming the data helped find the rule.
Mathematical explanation
Timing 10 swings and dividing by 10 reduces the effect of reaction time. The graph of time against length bends because the time grows more slowly than the length: four times the length gives only twice the time. Plotting time against √length straightens the curve, showing T = k√L. With lengths in metres, k is close to 2, so a pendulum about 25 cm long swings back and forth in about 1 second. The weight and (for small angles) the starting angle hardly matter.
Expected project output
A timing table, a curved graph and a straight transformed graph, the model T = k√L and a tested one-second pendulum.
Skills developed
- Careful measurement
- Non-linear modelling
- Data transformation
- Design from a model
Assessment criteria
- Timing uses multiple swings and repeats.
- The curved shape of the first graph is recognised.
- The transformed graph and model are correct.
- The one-second pendulum is designed and tested.
Extension challenge
Change the weight and the starting angle in separate tests. Show with data which variables matter and which do not.
Safety and inclusion
Use a small weight and keep faces away from the swing path. Make sure the support is firmly fixed.