Art + Math + Science + English
  1. Mathematics
  2. Class 6
  3. Project 16
Mathematics Through Experiments and Discovery

16The Perfect Lemon Sharbat: A Ratio Taste Test

Teams mix lemon sharbat in different ratios of lemon juice, sugar syrup and water, run a fair blind taste test with classmates, and find the favourite ratio. They then scale the winning recipe up for 40 glasses and decide which of two mixtures is "more lemony" using equivalent ratios and fractions.

Class and age
Class 6 · 11–12
Activity type
Group
Time needed
60 to 75 minutes
Difficulty
Medium
Estimated budget
৳30–৳80

Mathematical concepts

  • Ratio a : b : c
  • Equivalent ratios and simplest form
  • Comparing ratios by converting to fractions of the whole
  • Scaling a recipe
  • Fair testing (blind tasting, one variable at a time)

Learning objectives

  • Mix drinks accurately to a given ratio.
  • Decide which of two ratios is stronger by comparing fractions.
  • Scale a three-part ratio to a required total volume.
  • Plan and run a fair taste test and summarise the results.

Real-life connection

Cooks, juice sellers, chemists, pharmacists, builders mixing cement and sand, and farmers mixing fertiliser all work with ratios. Getting the ratio wrong can spoil a dish, weaken a wall or harm crops.

Materials required

  • 4 to 6 lemons, sugar, clean drinking water
  • A measuring spoon (a 5 ml teaspoon or a 15 ml tablespoon) and a measuring cup
  • Clean jugs or bottles, labelled A, B, C, D
  • Small disposable or washable cups for tasting
  • Scoring sheet (1 to 5 stars)

Step-by-step instructions

  1. Story (Dreamer & Co.): 'Our company is opening a sharbat stall at the school fair. We need one perfect recipe and we need to make 40 glasses of it. Let us experiment!'
  2. Prepare: the teacher (or a supervised group) squeezes the lemon juice and makes sugar syrup (1 part sugar dissolved in 1 part water).
  3. Plan four mixtures in the ratio juice : syrup : water. For example A = 1 : 2 : 7, B = 1 : 1 : 8, C = 2 : 2 : 6, D = 1 : 3 : 6. Use spoons as the "part".
  4. Predict: which will be most sour? Most sweet? Compare juice as a fraction of the whole: A = 1/10, B = 1/10, C = 2/10, D = 1/10.
  5. Mix accurately in clean labelled jugs.
  6. Blind taste test: tasters do not know the labels. Each tastes a small sip of each and gives 1 to 5 stars. Water between tastes.
  7. Results: find the mean and median score of each mixture. Which won?
  8. Simplify and compare: is C = 2 : 2 : 6 the same as 1 : 1 : 3? Which mixtures are equivalent?
  9. Scale up: one glass is 200 ml. 40 glasses need 8,000 ml. For the winning ratio, how many ml of each part? (Total parts first: for 1 : 2 : 7 there are 10 parts, so each part is 800 ml.)
  10. Reflection: 'Was the test fair? What would you change? What did you learn about comparing ratios?'

Mathematical explanation

A ratio compares parts: 1 : 2 : 7 means for every 1 spoon of juice there are 2 of syrup and 7 of water, 10 parts in all. Ratios can be simplified by dividing every part by the same number (2 : 2 : 6 = 1 : 1 : 3), and two ratios that simplify to the same thing taste the same. To compare strength, convert each part to a fraction of the whole: in 1 : 2 : 7, juice is 1/10 of the drink; in 1 : 1 : 3 it is 1/5 = 2/10, so it is twice as lemony. Comparing only the first numbers can mislead. To scale up, divide the total volume by the total number of parts to find one part, then multiply. A blind test is fairer because tasters cannot be influenced by labels or by who made each drink.

Expected project output

  • A mixture plan with ratios and fractions of the whole
  • A taste test score table with mean and median for each mixture
  • Simplified ratios and a list of equivalent mixtures
  • The scaled recipe for 40 glasses

Skills developed

Ratio, fractions, scaling, fair testing, data summary, teamwork.

Assessment criteria

  • Mixes accurately to the planned ratios.
  • Compares ratios using fractions of the whole.
  • Scales the recipe correctly with working.
  • Explains how the test was made fair.

Extension challenge

Calculate the cost per glass of the winning recipe (price of lemons, sugar). If you sell a glass for 15 taka, what is the profit per glass and the profit percentage?

Safety and inclusion

Use clean drinking water and clean hands and utensils. Check for allergies or health conditions (such as diabetes) before tasting; anyone may choose not to taste. Only an adult should cut lemons with a knife. Use one cup per taster.