Art + Math + Science + English
  1. Mathematics
  2. Class 12
  3. Project 24
Mathematics Through Innovation and Problem Solving

24Who Really Won? The Mathematics of Fair Voting

The class chooses a picnic spot by ranking three options. Then they count the same ballots in three different ways, plurality, instant run-off and the Borda count, and are surprised to find three different winners. Students compare the methods using pairwise contests, learn about fairness criteria and Arrow's famous result that no ranked voting method can satisfy every fairness rule, and design a voting method for a real class decision.

Class and age
Class 12 · 17–18
Activity type
Group
Time needed
2 sessions of 60 minutes
Difficulty
Challenging
Estimated budget
Almost free

Mathematical concepts

  • Preference schedules
  • Plurality, instant run-off and Borda count
  • Pairwise (Condorcet) comparisons
  • Fairness criteria
  • Arrow's impossibility theorem (in words)

Learning objectives

  • Count ranked ballots by several methods.
  • Find a Condorcet winner if one exists.
  • Compare methods using fairness criteria.
  • Design and justify a voting method for a real decision.

Real-life connection

Different countries, clubs, award juries and sports polls use different counting methods, and the choice of method can change the result. Understanding this helps citizens think clearly about fairness in decisions.

Materials required

  • Ballot slips for ranking options
  • A board for tallying
  • Calculators

Step-by-step instructions

  1. Warm-up with practice ballots: 15 voters rank three picnic spots A, B and C. 6 voters rank A > B > C, 5 rank C > B > A, and 4 rank B > C > A.
  2. Plurality: count only first choices. Who wins?
  3. Instant run-off: remove the option with the fewest first choices and move those ballots to their next choice. Who wins?
  4. Borda count: 2 points for a first choice, 1 for second, 0 for third. Add up. Who wins?
  5. Pairwise contests: compare each pair (A against B, B against C, A against C). Is there an option that beats every other one head to head?
  6. Discuss which result feels fairest and why. List the fairness rules each method breaks.
  7. Now hold a real class vote with ranked ballots (on a picnic spot, a class project or a theme day). Count it by all methods.
  8. Agree as a class which method to use in future and write a short "class constitution" explaining why.

Mathematical explanation

With these ballots plurality chooses A (6 first choices against 5 and 4). Instant run-off removes B (4 first choices); those 4 ballots go to C, giving C 9 against A's 6, so C wins. The Borda count gives A 6 × 2 = 12, B 6 + 5 + 4 × 2 = 19 and C 5 × 2 + 4 = 14, so B wins. Head to head, B beats A by 9 to 6 and beats C by 10 to 5, so B is the Condorcet winner, the option a majority prefers to each rival. The same ballots give three different winners, which shows that the counting method is a real choice. Arrow's theorem shows that with three or more options no ranked method can satisfy a short list of reasonable fairness rules all at once, so every method involves trade-offs.

Expected project output

Counts by each method for the practice ballots, a pairwise table, a list of fairness rules, results of a real class vote, and a short class constitution.

Skills developed

  • Systematic counting
  • Logical comparison
  • Civic reasoning
  • Respectful debate

Assessment criteria

  • The three practice winners (A, C, B) are found correctly.
  • The Condorcet winner B is identified with pairwise counts.
  • Fairness criteria are explained with examples.
  • The class constitution gives clear reasons for its choice.

Extension challenge

Find ballots for three options where no Condorcet winner exists (A beats B, B beats C, C beats A). What does this cycle mean for majority rule?

Safety and inclusion

Keep real class ballots anonymous and keep the topic light and non-political. Respect every classmate's vote.